Saturday, July 30, 2011

Taiwan’s Anti-Nuclear Politics

Course GLS490 Dr. Kenneth Quinones
Akita International University
July 18, 2011


Taiwan’s Anti-Nuclear Politics

Introduction


Taiwan is a relatively small island which is also called Formosa which means “a beautiful island” in Portuguese. The main island of Taiwan is one-tenth of the size of Japan. There are 23,138,381 people living there (Government Information Office, Republic of China (Taiwan), 2010). The reason why I focus on Taiwan in terms of the nuclear power plants issue is because researching this issue would be valid since it could affect Japan’s future decision about nuclear power.

The entire world was greatly shocked at the huge earthquakes and tsunami on this March and the Fukushima shock: the explosion of the nuclear power plants in Fukushima daiichi added insult to injury. After this disaster, the nuclear power plants became a target of criticism all over the world, and particularly in Taiwan too. The debate heated up even in the political level.

My main objective in this paper is to figure out how the Fukushima shock affected Taiwan’s politics and society and also how is this going to affect Japan’s future in return. In the following sections, I would like to talk about the status quo of the nuclear power plants and the history of anti-nuclear movement in a political level in Taiwan. Some similar characteristics of Taiwan’s nuclear power plants and Japan’s would be introduced in the next paragraph. Then, I will compare the two completely different stances toward the nuclear power plants in Taiwan. Moreover, I would like to look at the public opinion toward this nuclear power issue. In my conclusion I would like to consider about how this Taiwan’s trial and political change could affect Japan in the future.

Nuclear Power Plants in Taiwan

Nuclear power has also been controversial in Taiwan (WSJ). In Taiwan, the electricity is provided by Taiwan Power Company (Taiwan Power Company, 2011). They provide service to 12.58 million customers on the island of Taiwan and the Kinmen and Matsu islets. Taipower has 6 nuclear units installed in 3 stations and 2 units in a new station are under construction. Those four nuclear power plants are usually called as “the first” which is in Chinshan, “the second“ which is in Kuosheng, “the third” which is in Maanshan, and “the fourth” which is in Longmen. Other detailed information of those units is as follows. Also as the map shows, there are three units in the northernmost tip of Taiwan and one unit is in the southernmost tip of it.







Figure 1 Figure 2

Figure 1: Operating Taiwan nuclear reactors (World Nuclear Association, 2010).

Figure 2: Taiwan nuclear reactors under construction.








Figure 3

Figure 3: A map of Taiwan’s nuclear power plants (ICCN, 2011).


The construction of the nuclear power plants in Taiwan has started since the late 1970s. Three of them are now generating electricity and the fourth one, which is under the construction in longmen village new Taipei city, has been made since March in 1999 under the KMT’s administration (Xie, 2003).

However, according to Xie, on March 2000, Chen Shui-bian of DPP who has been taking the position of the Anti-nuclear power plants became the president, and on May of the same year the discussion whether they should stop the construction of the fourth power plant started and on October the construction itself temporary stopped until February in 2001. Even though the administrative court proposed a bill of referendum about the fourth plant, it was strongly opposed in legislative courts by the opposition party, which is mainly KMT. Uphill battle from hostile opposition parties have still continued. Under the DPP’s administration, Taiwan held the “10th No Nuke Asia Forum” in 2002. On July 2003, there was a demonstration to push the referendum about the Longmen nuclear power plant in Taipei (Xie, 2003).

Similarities between Taiwan and Japan

The situation surrounding nuclear power plants in Taiwan bears a resemblance to Japan’s. First, they are similar in their roots of energy resources, dependency on nuclear power plants and also geographic characteristics. Both are importing most of their energy resources. Japan and Taiwan import more than 95% of its energy resources from other countries: 96% (including Uranium) (Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry, 2007), and 99.3% (Kuomingtang Official Website, 2011) respectively. This data shows that energy resources of these both counties are depending on foreign countries.

Second, Japan depends on nuclear power plants to generate almost 30% of the total electricity and Taiwan’s nuclear power plants generate about 20% of its total electricity (Women in Nuclear Taiwan, 2010). Their dependency rates on nuclear power for their electricity are close. 20% or 30% are relatively a large portion of the total electric generating capacity. Therefore, for both of them, nuclear power is necessary for the stable distribution of electricity and also economic development. This even would be a serious matter of the national security.

However, there is another noteworthy similarity between them, q.e. these two countries are on the same quake zones according to Wall street journal “scores of reactors in quake zones” (The Wall Street Journal, 2011). According to the Wall Street journal, there are “dozens of nuclear reactors operate in earthquake-prone regions around the world. Among them, least 14 are in high-hazard areas.” The map below shows that all the Taiwan’s nuclear power plants are on this zone. “Most of those plants are in just two places: Japan and Taiwan, both islands with limited natural resources that have chosen the risks of nuclear calamity over complete dependence on foreign sources of energy.” (The Wall Street Journal, 2011). Taiwan’s four nuclear power plants are all in this quake zones.








Figure 4

Figure 4: Threat by Land and Sea (The Wall Street Journal, 2011)

Thus, the situation surrounding nuclear power plants in Taiwan and Japan has many similarities. Even though both of the counties are depending on nuclear power plants so far, especially after the Fukushima shock, it is a huge risk for Taiwan to keep having the nuclear power plants. Now, Taiwan is impaled on the horns of a dilemma.

A Role of the Nuclear Power Issue in Taiwan’s Politics

The nuclear power issue in Taiwan had an inauspicious start and still cannot get out of the shape of this confrontation between the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) and the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP). Because of the future presidential election in 2012, lately, Taiwan’s politics has been under the big battle.

Now, Taiwan’s government is run by KMT. There are two major political parties in Taiwan, one is KMT and its opposition party is DPP. Usually KMT gets larger support from people who are living in big cities in the north such as Taipei. DPP gets more support from people who are in the south especially in rural area.

There are two candidates for the presidential election now, one is President Ma Ying-jeou of the KMT and the other one is Tsai Ing-wen of the DPP. Tsai is the chairman of DPP. She gained higher approval rating within the DPP (Taipei Times, 2011).

According to the Taipei Times (2011), Tsai Ing-wen was nominated as DPP’s candidate for 2012 presidential election this April. If she is elected as a president next year, she is going to be the first woman president in Taiwan’s history. Tsai has a pragmatic point of view on the cross-strait relations, but has a strict position on Taiwan’s sovereignty status, that means Taiwan is an independent sovereign state and does not belong to Mainland China (Taipei Times, 2011)







Figure 5 Figure 6

Figure 5: KMT nominated Ma Ying-jeou and DPP nominated Tsai Ing-wen for the upcoming presidential election. If you had to vote today, for whom would you vote? (GVSRC, May 9-10, 2011).

Figure 6: Support rate of presidential candidates in 2012 (“Campaign Indicator” with estimated vote shares excluded) (GVSRC, 2011).


As the figure 5 and 6 show, now Tsai have to grapple with the severe present set of conditions.







Figure 7

Figure 7: Survey on President Ma Ying-jeou's Performance (GVSRC, May 24, 2011).




Figure 8
Figure 8: Respondents’ evaluations on possible changes in the cross-Strait relations if either candidate wins the presidency in 2012 (GVSRC, June, 2011).

Based on the figure 7, which is a survey conducted by Global View Survey Research Center (GVSRC) of Taiwan (2011), President Ma is getting more approval from public in terms of the cross-strait relations, which is one of the biggest and longest assignments for Taiwan. Furthermore, as the figure 8 shows, people in Taiwan have obviously a negative image against Tsai when it comes about the cross-Strait relations. According to the Taipei Times translated from liberty times, “She has spearheaded the DPP’s “10-year master plan,” a paper on how the party plans to tackle future challenges, such as an aging population, environmental degradation and the cross-strait policy, which is expected to play a key part in her campaign” (Taipei Times, 2011). Therefore, the environmental degradation, especially the non-nuclear politics will become a political trump card for her.

Comparison of Stances: Tsai and Ma

According to the official website of KMT (2011) and DPP (2011), it's not too much to say that they are taking opposite stances against nuclear power plants, especially on the 4th one. In the following two sections, each party’s stance and its supporters’ opinions will be discussed.

1. Tsai’s Anti-Nuclear campaign and its supporters

On March 25th right after the Fukushima shock, she proposed the campaign pledge: “Nuclear-free nation”: to abolish all the nuclear power plants in Taiwan by 2025. She said that it is impossible to stop all the nuclear power plants right now. The reason why she set 2025 as a goal is because that 2025 is the end year of duration life of the third power plant. That is, if the fourth plant is not built, by 2025 Taiwan’s nuclear power plants would all be expired. Tsai Ing-wen mentioned that risks and disadvantages of having the nuclear power plants are too huge in Taiwan. (The Epoch USA, 2011).

According to Taiwan Environmental Protection Union (TEPU) (2011), whole Taipei, the capital city would be within a 30-kilometer radius of the plants. The first and the second plants have already included the Taipei city its 30-kilometer radius, but if the fourth plant is completed and starts to be used, the whole northern part of Taiwan would be in danger if they exploded. The establishment of the fourth nuclear power plant means that 6,000,000 people in the northern part of Taiwan would be included within 30km of the main influential areas.






Figure 9
Figure 9: Whole Taipei would be within a 30-kilometer radius of the plants. (TEPU, 2011).

In her blog, Tsai Ing-wen insisted that the government and also people of course should try to save the energy in daily life. She also said that during this period Taiwan can find a lot of alternative energy, and also that the people in Taiwan have to change our industrial structure, so that industry can be compatible with the environment. At the same time, they should get out from the high-energy and high water consuming life style and then turn it into the industrial structure with high knowledge, high technology and high humanities. (Tsai, 2011).

The 2025 nuclear-free program of Taiwan is a complete set of idea, they are also planning that in 2025, Taiwan will be able to secede from the dependence on nuclear energy, to change the industrial structure and way of life can change, even to be able to find more alternative solutions to produce energy which are more efficient and clean (Democratic Progressive Party Official Website, 2011).

Moreover, Tsai mentioned that there is a written policy which tells that Taiwan is going to be a “Nuclear-free nation” gradually in the environmental fundamental law which was enacted in 2002. The storage of the electricity of last year achieved 23% already. The necessary electricity storage is only 15% (Tsai, 2011). Even if all the nuclear power plants were stopped, there would still be 10% of storage. Thus, what they have to do is to think about how to fill in this about 5% gaps. Some scholars such as Professor Shi Xin-min in the department of Chemical and Materials Engineering in National Taiwan University also expressed the same point of view (Liberty Times, March 25, 2011).

Tsai’s plan on how to replace nuclear power plants is as follows (Tsai, 2011). There are some methods that Tsai offered to tackle this assignment.

a. To improve the renewable energy resources: According to the governmental rule, it should be increased by 6.5% by 2025.
b. To improve the efficiency of the thermal electric power generation. By investing money into the thermal electric power generation, it is possible to increase 5.8% of the total electricity generated. By doing this, it would also cut the CO2 emission.
c. To build new natural gas electric power generators in priority rather than building the fourth nuclear power plant. By using the two previous methods, the electricity is already increased by more than 10%. If more electricity is needed, building new natural gas electric power generators would be cleaner and quicker.

Ong Jin-zhu of DPP said that Taiwan’s renewable energy equipment already can produce 6% of whole electricity. He said that it’s possible to replace the nuclear power by renewable energy and natural gas generators (Liberty Times, March 22, 2011). Against KMT and Taipower’s opinions that renewable energy is expensive, he insisted that if the same size of disaster as Japan happened in Taiwan, the prime cost would be higher.

Asian Week criticized that Taipower is not doing well and it is hard to trust them (2011). They said that the fourth plant has many problems. For example, since under the Chen’s administration the construction was stopped and postponed, the materials such as steel were eroded. They had some serious failures on the first generator’s design in the fourth plant, what they have done to fix it was to take some parts away from the second generator and put them in the first one. Tsai Ing-wen and her supporters mentioned as above and emphasized how it is risky to keep having the nuclear power plants in Taiwan.

2. Ma Ying-jeou’s stance and anti-Tsai’s pinion

Against Tsai’s campaign pledge, Ma Ying-jeou, an active president and chairman of KMT and other supporters such as officers of Taipower and administration of Ministry of Economic Affairs have been making strong appeals to the public talking about risks and disadvantages of not having the nuclear power plants in Taiwan. They are mainly emphasizing the economical disadvantage such as the fact that Taiwan. products might lose its competitiveness if they stop using the nuclear power plants.

Ma said that “I love Taiwan, I want Nuclear power plant safety, no safety no Taiwan.” (Kuomingtang Official Website, 2011). His stance toward the nuclear power plants is very clear. He thinks that it would be better for Taiwan’s economical development to keep building the fourth plant and try to improve the security against the possibility of natural disasters (World Nuclear Association, 2010). According to the World Nuclear Association, “Nuclear power is considerably cheaper than alternatives.” (2010). Lin Sheng-zhong, a vice-minister of administration of Ministry of Economic Affairs, R.O.C. also said that the alternatives’ prime cost is too high (Liberty times, March 22, 2011). Also, Ma emphasized that 99.3% of Taiwan’s energy resources are imported (Kuomingtang Official Website, 2011). Therefore, Nuclear power plants are important for Taiwan in terms of the national security. Nuclear power plants will provide stable and cheaper energy to the people in Taiwan.

Chen Gui-ming, the CEO of Taipower emphasized that the fourth plant has no problem so far (Liberty Times, March 22, 2011). Huang Xian-zhang, the Vice president of Taipower said that stopping the fourth plant means losing 260billion NT dollars (Liberty Times, March 26, 2011), which is almost 9 billion US dollars. If they didn’t continue to use the nuclear power plants in Taiwan, people will suffer from a lack of electricity within 8 years. Moreover, the Ministry of Economic Affairs, R.O.C. said that by abolishing the nuclear power plants, CO2 emission will be higher. (Liberty Times, March 26, 2011).

Shutting down all the nuclear power plant gives a huge negative impact on industries. Chen Zhao-yi, State-operated meeting vice-committee chairman said that almost 65% of electricity would be insufficient. There would be no way to make up for the lack of electricity without nuclear power plants. (Liberty Times, March 22, 2011). Thus, Ma Ying-jeou and nuclear power supporters are expressing strong concern mainly about negative impact on economy.

Public Reactions

What about the public opinion toward this issue then? According to TVBS TV Network, Poll Center, 60% of people in Taiwan expect the “Nuclear-free nation” (2011). However, as the figure 10 shows, 52% of people are not supporting the idea of “stopping the fourth plant”. 29% said that they highly support Tsai’s idea (TVBS TV Network, Poll Center, 2011). The reason why 52% of people said they don't support Tsai’s idea is because they worry about the possible negative impact on the development of Taiwan economy.







Figure 10

Figure 10: Do you agree with the Tsai’s idea of “stopping the fourth plant”? (TVBS TV Network, Poll Center, 2011).








Figure 11

Figure 11: If the electricity fee got more than 1.5 higher than now, do you agree or not? (TVBS TV Network, Poll Center, 2011).

For the question “if the electricity fee got more than 1.5 higher than now, do you agree or not?” 51% people said agree and 38% said disagree.








Figure 12

Figure 12: Concerning some impacts on economy, do you still agree with the Tsai’s idea of “stopping the fourth plant”? (TVBS TV Network, Poll Center, 2011).

However, interestingly if there would be a negative influence on economy, then 50% of people would not agree with the idea of stopping all the nuclear power plant and 38% said agree.








Figure 13
Figure 13: Which one do you believe: Taipower or Scholars? (TVBS TV Network, Poll Center, 2011).

46% of the people believe Taipower’s allegation that electricity wouldn't be enough a few years later if all the nuclear power plants were abolished, on the other hand, 43% believe the scholars’ opinion that even if they closed all the nuclear power plants, Taiwan still have enough electricity storage.







Figure 14
Figure 14: Is Tsai’s Anti-nuclear campaign clear enough for you? (TVBS TV Network, Poll Center, 2011).

71% of people answered that Tsai’s campaign is not clear enough and 26% said that it is very clear. This data shows that it is difficult for Tsai to get more support from the public due to the lack of understanding. As the TVBS TV Network, Poll Center’s survey data shows that main concern of the public is also the economic disadvantage. Even though Tsai offered plans to deal with the lack of electricity, it seems that her campaign is still not clear enough for ordinary people in Taiwan.

Conclusion

There have been many anti-nuclear movements in Taiwan for a long time, but especially after the Fukushima shock, this nuclear power issue became one of the main concerns for people in Taiwan followed after the cross-strait relations. Through this research I found that this issue is used as a political strategy for the presidential election by the two parties. It is obvious that all the information is controlled by them. Therefore, even though those two parties’ opinions are contradictory, it will be hard for ordinary people to decide which one is right and which one is wrong. It is impossible to abolish all the nuclear power plants right now in Taiwan. The future direction of Taiwan’s nuclear power plants is heavily depending on the two major political parties. The presidential election in 2012 would especially offer a new direction in this issue.

Since there were too much information and they are complicated, I will not dare to give any personal visions or anticipations about the presidential election. However, by observing the anti-Tsai’s opinions, it seems like their point of the argument is always linked to economical disadvantages. Now, a large number of people want a “Nuclear free nation” in Taiwan however many of them cannot support Tsai’s campaign because they are concerned about the influence on economy. The anti-Tsai’s opinions are sharply pointing out their concern. Therefore, if Tsai could explain about this aspect more clearly and communicate with the public sufficiently, her anti-nuclear campaign will be the political bargaining chip for Tsai to win the presidential election in 2012.

Now, the world is more and more swayed to no-nuke movement. After the Fukushima shock, Taiwan’s anti-nuclear movement became the one in political level. If Tsai won in the presidential election next year and implements the anti-nuclear policy, Japan will be affected by this movement too. If Taiwan which has many similarities with Japan took a step ahead to the “Nuclear-free nation”, this would be a billow to push the Japanese society and government toward the same direction. The chain effect of Fukushima shock will be settled soon in the future.




References

Asian Week. (April 3, 2011). Nuclear sticks like a bur and Taiwan doesn't know which way to turn. [Taiwan xingge zhijin henneg shiluan nanqi]. Retrieved July 3, 2011, from http://www.peopo.org/rousseau/post/79150

Democratic Progressive Party Official Website. (2011). Tsai Ying-wen: Win power in 2012, show Taiwan the direction toward the Nuclear-free nation by 2025. [Tsai Ying-wen 2012 Chongfan zhizheng, rang Taiwan zou xiang 2025 Feihejiayuan]. Retrieved June 6, 2011, from http://www.dpp.org.tw/news_content.php?sn=4944

Global Views Survey Research Center. (2011). Retrieved June 13, 2011, from http://www.gvm.com.tw/gvsrc/eng/index.asp

Government Information Office, Republic of China (Taiwan). (2010). Leaflet of ROC.
Retrieved July 18, 2011, from http://www.taiwanembassy.org/glance/jp/ch2.htm

ICCN. (2011). Drawing sheets of Taiwan’s nuclear power. Retrieved June 6, 2011, from http://www.iccnp.com/data3.html

Kuomingtang Official Website. (2011). Chairman Ma:”I love Taiwan, I want Nuclear power plant safety, no safety no Taiwan.” [Ma Zhuxi “Wo ai Taiwan, Wo yao hean, meiyou hean, meiyou Taiwan”] Retrieved July 7, 2011, from
http://www.kmt.org.tw/hc.aspx?id=32&aid=5893

Liberty Times. (March 22, 2011). Is it possible to make Taiwan in to nuclear-free nation? [ Feihejiayuan keneng ma? ]Retrieved July 3, 2011, from
http://www.peopo.org/rousseau/post/79150

Liberty Times. (March 25, 2011). Lawmaker plans freezing nucleus factory budget. [ Liwei ni dongjie hechang yusuan]. Retrieved July 3, 2011, from
http://www.peopo.org/rousseau/post/79150

Liberty Times. (March 26, 2011). By abolishing nuclear power plants, Taipower has to charge the electricity fee about 1.5 times than it used to be. [Feihedian Taidian: Meidu dianfei 2.62yuan bian4yuan]. Retrieved July 3, 2011, from
http://www.peopo.org/rousseau/post/79150
Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry. (2007). Agency for Natural Resources and Energy (ANRE) broacher: the situation of Japan’s energy. [Nihon no enerugi jijou]. Retrieved July 4, 2011, from http://www.enecho.meti.go.jp/topics/energy-in-japan/energy2008html/japan/index.htm

Taipei Times. (April 28, 2011). DPP’s Tsai to run for president. Retrieved June 6, 2011,
from http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/front/print/2011/04/28/2003501865

Taiwan Power Company. (2011). Household electricity consumption guide. Retrieved July 18, 2011, from http://www.taipower.com.tw/indexE.htm

Taiwan Environmental Protection Union. (2011). Don’t let Taiwan become like Fukushima-611 whole Taiwan Anti-nuclear movement. [Mo rangjiayuanbianfudao 611 quantai fanhe xingdong]. Retrieved June 28, 2011, from www.tepu.org.tw

The Wall Street Journal. (March 19, 2011). Scores of Reactors in Quake Zones: Japan, Taiwan Account for Most Sites in High-Activity Areas; 'Large Margins of Safety' Factored In at U.S. Plants. Retrieved June 6, 2011, from http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703512404576208872161503008.html

The Epoch USA. (March 25, 2011). Tsai Ying-wen: “Anti-nuclear power” It is necessary to abolish the fourth plant. [Tsai Ying-wen ”Feihe” feifeihesi]. Retrieved July 12, 2011, from http://www.epochtimes.com/b5/11/3/25/n3209083.htm

Tsai Ying-wen’s blog. (March 28, 2011 ). 13-years-effort, to get rid of the fear of nuclear disaster in future Taiwan-Nuclear-free nation should be implemented. [Shisan niande nuli, rang xiayidai mianyu hezaide kongju- feihejiayuan xuyao shijian] .Retrieved July 6, 2011, from
http://www.iing.tw/2011/03/blog-post_28.html

Tsai Ying-wen’s blog. (March 26, 2011 ). Tsai Ying-wen: Nuclear-free nation by 2025: Tsai Ying-wen 2025.[Nian dacheng feihejiayuan]. Retrieved July 6, 2011, from http://www.iing.tw/p/2025.html

TVBS TV Network, Poll Center (April 8, 2011). The opinion poll about the debate of nuclear power plants. [Heneng fadian zhengyi mindiao]. Retrieved July 13, 2011, from http://www.tvbs.com.tw/news/news_poll.asp?p=1&k=0

Women in Nuclear Taiwan. (2010). Nuclear Power Program. Retrieved June 13, 2011, from http://www.wintaiwan.org/wintaiwan/data/npg_eng.html

World Nuclear Association. (2010). Nuclear Power in Taiwan. Retrieved June 13, 2011, from http://www.world-nuclear.org/info/inf115_taiwan.html

Xie, M. (2003). Establishment of the fourth nuclear power plant in Taiwan and its relationship with Japan. [Taiwan daiyon genshiryoku hatudensho no kennsetsuto Nihonntoo kakawar]. Retrieved June 6, 2011, from
http://homepage3.nifty.com/anshin-kagaku/sub031113taiwandai4.htm

Japan-Taiwan Relations: Territorial Dispute in Senkaku Islands/Diaoyutai

Japan-Taiwan Relations: Territorial Dispute in Senkaku Islands/Diaoyutai

July 22, 2011

Introduction

My personal impression on the relationship between Japan and Taiwan is quite good but quite unfair. The human interaction between Taiwan and Japan is stably active every year as you can see in the Figure 1. Taiwanese people are really nice to Japanese people. For further understanding of Taiwan, I would like to focus on the Japan-Taiwan relations in terms of the fight over the ownership of Senkaku islands/ Diaoyutai. Even though on September in 2010, there was a huge conflict between Japan and mainland China, where a fishing ship of mainland China hit the ships of Japan Coast Guard, I am not going to talk about this incident in this paper.


Figure 1

Figure 1: transitional change of human interaction. The number of Japanese people who have visited Taiwan and Taiwanese people who have visited Japan (Interchange Association, Japan (IAJ), 2011).

A recent Incident near Senkaku

On June 29, an incident happened near the Senkaku islands (Searchina, 2011). According to Asahi Shinbun, in the morning of June 29th, two Taiwanese activists of the ROC Association of Protect Diaoyutai(中華保釣協會)who have been claiming Taiwan’s sovereignty over Senkaku islands, rode on a fishing ship ”Dafa 268” and came really close to the islands. Japan Coast Guard found the ship and gave them a warning. After that, the ship returned its way. There were no troubles at that time. Yet, this created tension between Japan and Taiwan (The Asahi Shinbun Company, June 29, 2011).

  2011 is the 40th year of Chinese people’s protest movements over the Senkaku issue. Therefore, it is an important milestone in their activities. They once considered Japan’s present situation which was severely damaged by the earthquake in this March, but they changed their mind later on and still camenear Senkaku islands to mount a protest (The Asahi Shinbun Company, June 29, 2011). 

Brief Historical Background of Senkaku

After the First Sino-Japanese War from 1894 to ’95, “the Government of Japan made a Cabinet Decision on January 14th, 1895 to erect a marker on the Islands to formally incorporate the Senkaku Islands into the territory of Japan (Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan” (MOFA of Japan), 2011). In 1969, the Economic Commission for Asia and the Far East (ECAFE) conducted a survey on the bottom of the ocean and found out that the seabed near the Senkaku Islands were full of resources (All About, March 29, 2003). This was the trigger of the Sovereignty issue over the Senkaku Islands. In 1971, the government of the Republic of China (ROC), which was still a legitimate Chinese government in the international society, officially declared Taiwan’s sovereignty over the Senkaku islands (All About, March 29, 2003).

Stances of Japanese Government and Taiwanese Government

Japanese government’s stance toward this issue is that there is no territorial issue because Senkaku Islands are legitimately included to Japanese territories. Japanese government insists that the US have also mentioned that they returned the Senkaku islands as Japan’s territory when they returned Okinawa (Yahoo Japan Corporation, 2011). This is the Japanese government’s official declaration about the Sovereignty over the Senkaku Islands.

These islands were neither part of Taiwan nor part of the Pescadores Islands which were ceded to Japan from the Qing Dynasty of China in accordance with Article II of the Treaty of Shimonoseki which came into effect in May of 1895.

Accordingly, the Senkaku Islands are not included in the territory which Japan renounced under Article II of the San Francisco Peace Treaty. The Senkaku Islands have been placed under the administration of the United States of America as part of the Nansei Shoto Islands, in accordance with Article III of the said treaty, and are included in the area, the administrative rights over which were reverted to Japan in accordance with the Agreement Between Japan and the United States of America Concerning the Ryukyu Islands and the Daito Islands signed on 17 June 1971. The facts outlined herein clearly indicate the status of the Senkaku Islands being part of the territory of Japan. (MOFA of Japan, 2011).

On the other hand, Taiwanese government officially asserted that Senkaku Islands’ territory and sovereignty belong to the Republic of China. Taiwan government rose geographical, terrestrial formation, long-term-use (over 100 years) of the sea area near Senkaku, and historical approach to insist on the sovereignty over Senkaku Islands.

Figure 2

Figure 2: Senkaku Islands are the territory of the Republic of China. Geographically, they are Taiwanese associated islands, and belong to Ilan County (MOFA, Taiwan, 2011).

Conclusion

As the previous information shows, Japan’s position is backed by some international treaties. On the other hand, Taiwan’s position pretty much depends on how they look at the history and their opinions are not legitimate enough based on the international law. Therefore, Taiwan’s opinion is taken as far-fetched story in the international society.

Since mainly three nations: Japan, Taiwan and mainland China are claiming their sovereignty over the Senkaku islands, There are contradictions for Taiwan toward this issue. Because Taiwan is now suffering from the cross-strait relationship with China, Taiwan cannot cooperate with China on this issue, for the reason that Taiwanese sovereignty might be invaded. It seems like Taiwan cannot strongly or violently approach this issue because the relationship with Japan might get worse. Taiwan is economically relying on Japan and not only on China as it was the case decades ago. When I looked at the President’s comments about this issue between Japan, I got an impression that he is relatively rational and calm to talk about it (Office of the President Republic of China (Taiwan), Oct 8, 2008). Thus the Senkaku issue is very complicated since it is not only about Japan-Taiwan relationship but also China-Taiwan, Japan-China relationship, and even Japan-US relationship too.

I am not a politically correct person, so I am not really sure about what is right about this issue. However, I personally have a deep emotional attachment to Taiwan and Taiwanese people, so hopefully they can solve this problem in a more peaceful and friendly way in the future.


Reference

Interchange Association, Japan (IAJ). (2011). 日台関係. Retrieved July 15, 2011, from

http://www.koryu.or.jp/ez3_contents.nsf/12/F3CE8A140E14BA4649257737002B2217?OpenDocument

All About. (2003.03.29) 尖閣諸島問題の基礎知 Retrieved July 19, 2011, from

http://focus.allabout.co.jp/gm/gc/293247/?from=dailynews.yahoo.co.jp

Yahoo Japan Corporation. (2011) What the Senkaku issue is. Retrieved July 19, 2011, from

http://dailynews.yahoo.co.jp/fc/domestic/senkaku/

Ministry of Foreign affairs of Japan. (2011). The Basic View on the Sovereignty over the

Senkaku Islands. Retrieved July 19, 2011, from

http://www.mofa.go.jp/mofaj/area/senkaku/index.html

Ministry of Foreign Affairs Republic of China (TAIWAN). (2009). Retrieved July 19, 2011, from http://www.mofa.gov.tw/webapp/ct.asp?xItem=40531&ctNode=2038&mp=1

Ministry of Foreign Affairs Republic of China (TAIWAN). (February, 2003).The ROC government reiterates its sovereignty over the Tiaoyutai Islands. Retrieved July 19, 2011, from http://www.mofa.gov.tw/webapp/ct.asp?xItem=7843&ctNode=1903&mp=6

Searchina. (2011). 尖閣で「あわや衝突」、台湾活動家の漁船と日本巡視船が=中国. Retrieved July 19, 2011, from http://news.searchina.ne.jp/disp.cgi?y=2011&d=0701&f=politics_0701_005.shtml

The Asahi Shinbun Company. (June 29, 2011). 台湾活動家の船、尖閣海域に入る 警告受け引き返す. Retrieved July 19, 2011, from http://www.asahi.com/international/update/0629/TKY201106290602.html

Office of the President Republic of China (Taiwan). (Oct 8,2008). 總統接受日本「世界雜誌」專訪, Retrieved July 21, 2011, from

http://www.president.gov.tw/Default.aspx?tabid=131&itemid=14246&rmid=514

Taiwan's food culture

Comment on "Taiwan's food culture"

July 21, 2011

Taiwan has diversified and complex food culture which rooted in its history and geography. Because of the ethnic variety, there are many different cultures in Taiwan. Even though I have lived in Taiwan more than two years, I have never look at its food culture in this way before. I haven’t thought that complexity of Taiwanese history and cultural diversity is correlated each other.

I have often told my friends that I love “Taiwanese food” because they are all so delicious. However, I have never thought about the origins of each one of them. When I looked back the days when I was still in Taiwan, I remembered that many of my favorite restaurants had some names of places such as Suzhou, Hangzhou, Hainan, Jiangsu, Yunnan, Shanghai and also HongKong. They were all similar for me, but some dishes were different from foods that I have eaten near my house in Taiwan, which were mostly in some restaurants in Shida night market area.

Based on the idea of diversity, I realized that foods in Taiwan are truly influenced from other countries such as Thai, Vietnam, Spain, France, Japan, Mexico etc. However, as for Japanese food, (because I cannot tell any differences between the down-to-earth foods in those countries and in Taiwan’s, I’m going to only talk about Japanese food in Taiwan.) I could tell that the taste of Japanese foods in Taiwan was most the time, not exactly like Japan’s. Most of the Taiwanese-Japanese foods were relatively sweeter than Japanese ones. Yet, they were all still very good. I thought that Taiwanese people are very good at imitating the skill of cooking and taking in the good part of each dish from different countries and cooking it into delicious Taiwanese-like taste.

There are many different kinds of restaurant in Taiwan. This mixture of culture also made the food culture of Taiwan more attractive. Because of the complex history, Taiwanese people are generous to different cultures and people from different places. Even though some people said that Taiwan doesn’t have its own unique culture, I think this diversity is the “Taiwanese culture” and it is very unique.

Taiwan's National Identity Issue

Comment on Taiwan's National Identity Issue

July 11, 2011

Since my seminar paper topic is also related to Taiwan’s national identity, I’m very much interested in this topic. In the reading, the author mainly discussed the four symbolic changes which are redefinitions of National Identity. Taiwan’s national identity is always linked to its differentiation from mainland China.

I am presently working on writing a research paper about the identity of Taiwan’s younger generation and their sentiment toward mainland China. According to my research, 127 people out of 139 said that they define themselves as “Taiwanese”, not “Chinese”. From this result, I think I can say that this generation is sort of the result of “Taiwanization”. Some of them had used the “Knowing Taiwan” textbook when they were junior high school students. I first thought that they might have gotten some influences from the textbooks of history, geography, and social studies textbook through their junior high school education. However, as I do more research, I started to feel the present political situation would have a stronger influence on the thoughts of the younger generation.

Therefore, when I look back on the period when the tridemism was overthrown or when textbooks were recompiled many times (This period is the transitional period of taiwanization/ de-sinicization), each event was real and personal for the people in Taiwan at that time. There must have been a lot more of Waishenrens who strongly believed that Taiwan and mainland China should be unified. Especially after 1987, Benshenrens’ idea that Taiwan should be an independent nation must have been stronger than now too.

When I look at the banknote, I see some Chinese elements and Taiwanese elements. Therefore I suppose how both parties should come to terms with each other must have been an important matter in Taiwanese politics and society at that time. Through this period of transition, the people in Taiwan have been gradually Taiwanized and as I mentioned above, the younger generation feel a stronger Taiwanese identity naturally, which should be differentiated from mainland China.

Saturday, June 18, 2011

The Japan-Taiwan Relations

The Japan-Taiwan Relations

<Taiwan Society Today>

I have watched the movie”Cape No.7” so many times before. I remember it was a very popular movie in 2009 in Taiwan. When I watched the movie, I was quite surprised that even though this movie describes the historical matter between Japan and Taiwan from Taiwanese point of view, the way they express Japan and Japanese people were quite different from other Chinese, Korean, or even Japanese movies which talked about the Japanese colonial period. In this Cape No.7, there are two love stories between Taiwanese people and Japanese people going on simultaneously. Even though it already passed about 60 years since Japanese left Taiwan after the Second World War, their love hasn’t end and another love story in the younger generation started. I think this implies that Taiwan still considers Japan as a good partner and friends even now and in the future.

I myself have lived in Taiwan for 2 years and more. I felt that Taiwanese people are very nice to Japanese people. I have been helped by many nice Taiwanese people in Taiwan. Especially when I went to Taiwan in this March, I realized their love toward Japan very clearly. Since I flew to Taipei on March 6 from Sendai airport, I was in Taipei when the earthquake and Tsunami occurred in Japan. Therefore, I could see and feel how Taiwanese people tried to support Japan in real.

Their reaction was very big and their actions were so quick. Many people were doing charity activities for Japan in everywhere. They even made 4-hour-charity TV program, and collected donation. As a result, Taiwan donated more than 5 billion and 7 hundred million Japanese yen. I was watching the TV program on time in Taiwan, it was very heartwarming.

However, after I came back to Japan, I found that most of Japanese people don’t know what Taiwan actually had done for us. It was because that the Japanese government gave pressures on broadcasting companies not to tell about it to Japanese people too much. It is said that they concerned about Japan-China relationship. For the government, the Japan-China relationship always comes first rather than Taiwan.

As I already mentioned in the last discussion session, the cross-strait relationship is changing time by time. I am on my way doing the research for my East Asian Studies seminar about A comparative survey about the Taiwan-younger generation’s public emotion toward the Mainland China based on their self-identification, and the comparison of their sense of intimacy and credibility to following major five foreign countries: the US, Japan, the Mainland China and Korea. I am still collecting the questionnaire, but when I looked at the results which I have collected so far, I noticed that the Taiwanese younger generation has better image toward the mainland China while they still having the Taiwanese identity. This was very surprising for me.

Thinking about Japan-China relationship is of course important. Yet, Japan must think about how to make Japan-Taiwan relation better and fair more seriously.

I decided to contribute to the Japan-Taiwan relations as a Japanese teacher in local level as a soft power in the future!!

Friday, December 10, 2010

The sociolinguistics of Hong Kong and the space for Hong Kong English

The sociolinguistics of Hong Kong and the space for Hong Kong English

 

Group 3: 

 

Course: Sociolinguistics

 

October 18, 2010


 

Introduction: Sociolinguistic reality in Asia

There are four sociolinguistic realities in Asia which we should know before talking about the sociolinguistic of Hong Kong and the space for Hong Kong English.

First sociolinguistic reality is that there is a paradigm shift to the World Englishes. It had been said that English belonged to the U.S. and UK. In these days, however, it is not true. There are many Englishes and English has even the status of a second language in some Asian societies such as India, Malaysia and Singapore as we learned in World Englishes by Braj B. Kachru.

              Second one is that in Asia people who have different mother tongues communicate with each other through English. As a result, English has acculturated in Asian societies where there is no shared Judeo-Christian or European cultural heritage.

             Third one is that English is the most demand for acquisition of bilingualism/multilingualism in Asia. In 1997, there were already 350 million people who used English and India is the third largest English-using nation after U.S. and UK.

Moreover, in some Asian societies, English is assuming the role of first language.

              Fourth one is that English could be a liberating language. According to the article, ‘once a language establishes its autonomy, it is actually liberated, and its “liberated” uses and functions have to be separated from its non-liberated uses.’ So in the case of Hong Kong English, we know that it comes from British English because of the colonization by England. Now it has its autonomy, which means it is free from the British English structure. Also it has its own characteristics which original British English doesn’t have. So we can say that Hong Kong English is the liberated English.

              In the later sections of this paper, we can see how Hong Kong English is liberated from the British English structure in terms of statistics, history, linguistic issues and criteria of World Englishes.

Monolingual Myth

Throughout the 1980s and 1990s, most of the linguists in Hong Kong were quite reluctant to be cognizant of some forms that multilingualism takes in the Hong Kong society. Instead, they focused on researching about the dominance of Cantonese in a variety of domains in Hong Kong. The primary reason why they were insisting on the monolingualism in Hong Kong was that they persistently had stuck to the fact that approximately 98 % of the total population was Cantonese-speaking Chinese. Hence, they considered English was not so much a second language as a foreign language, as the majority of the people there did not need to speak English in their daily communication.

A variety of survey and census conducted during 1980s and 1990s indicate that the total population of the English speakers in Hong Kong expanded drastically in a decade. In 1983, the total number of English speakers in Hong Kong was no more than 6.6%, however after the educational reform at the secondary level of education in 1970s, and the same reform at the university level of education in 1980s and 1990s, the number of the English speakers expanded up to 33.7% in 1993.

The result of the survey conducted by Bacon Shone and Bolton in 1993 indicates that 54% of the people in Hong Kong use English when they do any writing activities at work, and that 59% of the people normally read materials in English at work.

As far as the print media is concerned, the dominance of Chinese language is quite clear. There are 52 news papers published in Hong Kong, and the 50 of them are written in Chinese language, and only 2 are written in English. However, in the private domain of Hong Kong families, English is becoming more and more used in a wide range of varieties. Bacon and Bolton’s survey also show that many of the Hong Kong families have proximity with English language in their everyday lives.

Bacon Shone and Bolton affirm that Hong Kong society is far from monolingual after a series of surveys they had conducted. In Hong Kong, 98% of the people use Cantonese in their daily communication, and 33.7% of the people have a knowledge of English language which is indispensable when people do business, and receive education, and the number of Putonghua speakers is also increasing with the advent of Chinese economic super power. Furthermore, there are also minority languages in Hong Kong such as Malay Tagalog, as many people outside of Hong Kong have immigrated into Hong Kong over years. By far the largest of all groups is Filipinos. They are generally hired as a maid in Hong Kong families. The number of Filipinos has increased from 72,000 in 1991 to 170,000 in 1999. They make a contribution not only to the development of the Hong Kong economy, but also to improving children’s English conversation skills, as they have to speak English when communicating with these Filipino maids.

As we have gone through, there are so many factors that deny the idea of monolingualism in the Hong Kong society. Hong Kong society where various kinds of ethnic groups are in an existence should in no way be called monolingual. It is the society where a variety of languages are general used; multilingual.

History

              The history of Hong Kong was very important to understand how English was introduced to Hong Kong and how the language policies had been developed. From 18th to 19th, distinct variety of Chinese pidgin English emerged in Canton and Macau because of the development of the Canton trade. After the First Opium War between Britain and China, Hong Kong was annexed in 1842. The annexation brought many mission schools in Hong Kong, and people received English-medium education. However, Chinese language and literature were also taught in schools. In 1920s and 1930s, there was increasing number of Chinese-medium schools as well. In 1960s, there was the rise in the movement to Chinese language; Chinese-language university institution was established. There was Chinese language campaign in 1970s, and Chinese became a co-official language in 1974. Since then, education reforms were carried out, and compulsory primary and secondary schooling began. Hong Kong itself had been developed in this period: the growth of the city, and the population expansion caused by a lot of refugees.
              In 1980s, amendments to the Official Language Ordinance made the use of spoken Chinese extended into the higher courts. In 1986, the written laws of Hong Kong were translated into Chinese by “Bilingual Laws Project”. Many Hong Kong businessmen moved into China trade and there was the growth of a new middle class in 1980s. In 1992, the basic law of Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, Article 9 said that Chinese language and English are to be used as an official language. In 1995, Hong Kong government announced the new language policy that is “to develop a civil service which is biliterate in English and Chinese and trilingual in English, Cantonese and Putonghua.” Finally Hong Kong was handed over to People’s Republic of China in 1997.
              From 1960s to 1990s was the period of the late British Colonialism, and it created “modern Hong Kong”. After the annexation in 1842, education was conducted first in English, but gradually the use of Chinese language has been extended with the development of education, economy and society.

HK Issue

              As it is now clear that English had been used as an official language and educational medium in Hong Kong because of the British colonial rule which had lasted about one hundred years, “handover” to People’s Republic of China (PRC) greatly changed the situation.  That is, as it is mentioned in history part, PRC announced Article 9, Basic Law of the HKSAR which authorized Putonghua. This law was quite crucial in terms of replacing language position in Hong Kong, thus Putonghua suddenly came to the first place, and English and Cantonese had been placed aside. Such PRC’s position inevitably called confrontation versus Cantonese. As for the side of Hong Kong, they maintained that Cantonese language had a solid position in the Hong Kong society. TV, pop songs, magazine, newspaper and even the government were all using it. Clearly Cantonese was much more than vernacular for people residing in Hong Kong, and they strongly denied the policy. Contrary to such an objection, PRC insisted their language reform policy and Cantonese should be recognized as a regional dialect such as Shanghainese. This claim was based on the fact that Hong Kong was a part of PRC, so official language in Hong Kong naturally should be the same as that of PRC, thus Putonghua, so-called Mandarin Chinese.

              The issue here is not only about the battle between Cantonese and Putonghua, but also the choice, Cantonese or English. Since English has been used in Hong Kong for decades of years, both languages became teaching mediums at schools. Prestigious secondary schools were English-medium, and the door was allowed only for wealthy people. For the lowest rank of schools, on the contrary, Cantonese was used as a teaching medium, and schools in between offered classes in both English and Cantonese. Facing at such an educational disparity, local parents and communities strongly demanded for English-medium schools. This was because Universities in Hong Kong had adopted English as their teaching medium, so it was quite hard for children learning at the lowest rank of schools to pass the entrance exam. Responding to this kind of demands, by 1994, over ninety percent of all secondary schools were English medium. Worried at the risk of linguistic and cultural imperialism, however, Hong Kong government was a little reluctant to spread English-medium education. As the evidence of this hesitance, in 1997, the colonial Hong Kong government which was about to leave the island suddenly announced its encouragement of Cantonese as a teaching medium. Thus, throughout the history of Hong Kong, it was really wavering and undecided about their language policy, and that brought linguistic confusion or more positively, variety over Hong Kong as it can be still observed today.

5 Criteria for World Englishes

              As the group one presented already before, there is a concept: World Englishes in the world. English is not the inner circle countries’ dominant language anymore. In Hong Kong which belongs to the outer circle, people use their own English which is liberated from the structure of the English which is used in countries in the inner circle. There is a linguist whose name is Bulter. He proposed the 5 Criteria for World Englishes: 1). Accent which is “standard and recognizable pattern of pronunciation handed down from one generation to another”, 2). Vocabulary which is “particular words and phrases which spring up usually to express key features of the physical and social environment and which are regarded as peculiar to the variety” 3). A history which is “a sense that this variety of English is the way it is because of the history of the language community.”  4). Literary creativity which is “a literature written without apology in that variety of English.” and 5). Reference works which is “dictionaries and style guides which show that people in that language community look to themselves, not some outside authority, to decide what is right and wrong in terms of how they speak and write in their English”.   In this section, I would like to support the idea of “Hong Kong English” as one of the world Englishes using these 5 criteria.

              First, when I look at the Hong Kong accent, there are a number of localized features in Hong Kong English. According to the research by Bolton and Kwok, local speakers could recognize a Hong Kong accent relatively easily but they had difficulty in labeling other accents of English such as US accent or British accent. A substantial number of people stated a preference for that accent of English associated with “Hong Kong bilinguals”. Hong Kong English has unique accent on its own.

              Second, as for Hong Kong vocabulary, I could see a lot of interesting lexical borrowing from Chinese, in this case mainly from Cantonese, into English. I picked up some examples from the reading material: “ABC” stands for American or Australian Born Chinese, “banana” describes a westernized Chinese, “black society” means a Chinese secret society or triad and “astronaut” is used as a word for a person whose family has emigrated abroad, but who remained working in Hong Kong, and then spends a great deal of time flying between his or her family and Hong Kong. Those are all influenced by Chinese and used in Asian context, therefore different from other Englishes.

              Third, Hong Kong has a long history of linguistic contact with English that dates back to the 17th century. Furthermore, through the history from the late 1960s to the 1990s especially, people in Hong Kong saw the recognition of a distinct “Hong Kong identity” and the transformation of a colonial city to a global city. Thus, English in Hong Kong got its prestige in Hong Kong society. In Hong Kong, if you could speak English, you would be regarded as a “Hong Kong Man” who is “go-getting and highly competitive, tough for survival, quick-thinking and flexible”.  Throughout the history, Hong Kong English is one of the keys of new identifications of the “cosmopolitan” Hong Kong.

              Fourth, Even though a linguist Chan’s pessimistic idea against the literary creativity in English in Hong Kong, there are actually a significant number of creative works published by local writers in recent years.

              Last one is reference works. When I look at other countries in the outer circle such as Singapore, India, and Philippines, there are some dictionaries or style guides of their local variety of English. In Hong Kong actually also there are some companies or linguists who are working on making a dictionary of variety of  English in Hong Kong, or compiling a database of around one million words of English there as a part of the worldwide ICE project.

              Varieties of English are not only created from above, but also bubble up from below too. For example, the language of ICQ which is one of the computer communication tools as well as MSN messenger or Skype chatting, is English, sometimes it is possible to see a distinct code-mixing and hybrid variety. Please refer to the attached material as an example. Hence, these 5 criteria are sufficiently persuasive or powerful concept to support the idea of “Hong Kong English”.

Conclusion

              Through this paper, we understand 3 points. One is that Hong Kong is not a monolingual but a multilingual country.  They speak English, Cantonese, and Chinese. And their English, which is Hong Kong English, is one of the World Englishes as we examined in 5 criteria of World Englishes. Second point is that Hong Kong’s policies were changed along the history. People in Hong Kong used to speak Cantonese. However, after the annexation, they started to use English especially in education field. Then, since 1960’s some governmental policies and movements made people use Chinese as well. So, the current linguistic situation in Hong Kong is complicated. Third point is 2 linguistic battles in Hong Kong. In our paper, we paid attention to the battle between English and Cantonese. However, English has the higher status than Cantonese and Chinese now, because English used to be the only one official language from the annexation to 1974. So rather than the battle between English and Cantonese, the linguistic battle between Cantonese and Chinese is more heated in Hong Kong now. This is because of the different opinions about Cantonese and different opinions about writing system between Hong Kong and People’s Republic of China. Throughout this research, we think that Hong Kong might be a good model when we think about Japan as a cosmopolitan from the sociolinguistic point of view in the future.

My perspective about future energy resources

My perspective about future energy resources

B0601196

              Global warming is a serious problem nowadays. According to Al Gore’s movie The Inconvenient Truth, most of the scientists in the world agree with this idea. At the same time, we are facing the energy crisis. Therefore it is important for us to think about how to sustain our planet with clean renewable energy. Through the field trip to the Rokkasho Next Generation Energy Park, I could learn a lot of complicated but interesting and useful information to solve this one of the serious global environmental issue even though some of them are still problematic and very controversial. In this paper, I would like to organize what I learned in the Rokkasho Village, and to look at the merit and demerit of the each energy recourse: 1) Fossil Fuel, 2) Wind Power, 3) Nuclear Power, and 4) Fusion Energy respectively and then consider about the direction that we should take toward the future from my point of view. 

Fossil Fuel

First of all, it is obvious that our life and our economy are depending on fossil fuel which is a precious natural resource very much now.  About 50~60% of Japanese electricity comes from thermal power system which uses fossil fuel but Japan imports almost all of the fossil fuel from other countries. Through the oil crisis, triggered by the Middle East War in 1973, Japan Noticed that depending energy resources on importing is quite unstable and risky for national security and decided to stockpile petroleum in the Mutsu-Ogawara National Petroleum Stockpiling Base and other 9 National Petroleum Stockpiling Bases to take all measures necessary for release of oil in emergency. According to Miss. Ogase in the base, we can get 12 days necessary oil for entire Japan from this base. On the 2,400,000-square-meter site, there are the 51 storage tanks. Those tanks were very large and each one of them had almost as tall as a 4-story building.

Each country is struggling to find more stable resources in the world. Many countries are now trying to get more oil by drilling offshore. However, the problem is that fossil fuel is running out. We are under the extreme pressure of shortage of energy recourse. Even bigger problem of using fossil fuel is of course CO2 emission. This green house gas brings the global warming forward rapidly and causes other global issues such as loss of the land area as sea levels rise, change of ecosystem, deforestation, and desertification and so on. Thus I believe that we should stop using fossil fuel as soon as possible and look for renewable energy for our future. 

Wind Power

Wind power is one of the widely watched renewable energy resources. When I visited the Mutsu-Ogawara wind farm, I saw many wind turbines there. Those white, tall, and huge wind turbines were left with overwhelming impression on me. I thought the view which those white towers standing on the grassland, was so beautiful. I have seen those wind turbines before in my home prefecture; Yamagata. However this was my first time to look at the whole of them and study about it precisely. They are all much taller than I expected and much heavier for its looks. Their blades are imported from Denmark, and they are made by fiberglass therefore it must be lighter. It was very amazing that they will stop the rotor if the wind speed became slower than 3km/s and also they can adjust their directions depending on the wind.

There were 21 wind turbines in the farm and each one of them generates 1,500kW which would cover about 750 to 800 household. In this wind farm, they generate approximately 5,800,000 kWH electricity which might cut about 43,000T/yr CO2 off. I have been thinking if we could get energy from nature without exhaling any green house gasses, it would be fantastic and we don't have to worry about energy shortage anymore. Then what is the problem of this technology? The answer is that this technology wouldn't be out of proportion to the benefit. When it comes to value for money, they cannot generate enough energy. That is why even though wind power is a remarkable renewable energy resource, they cannot replace the thermal power system.

Nuclear Power

Nuclear Power Plant and other related facilities are the one which have gotten a lot of attention recently because this is also one of the renewable energy resource and controversial technology. Nuclear power plant occupies 30% of the Japan’s electricity generation now. My image about the Nuclear Power Plant was that it does not generate CO2 but once some accidents happened, it will kill a lot of people, and damage huge area.

The whole process of generating electricity using nuclear power was not easy. There are many steps to produce electricity and recycle it again. First, they convert uranium into uranium hexafluoride (UF6), then in uranium concentration plant they enrich uranium from 0.7% to 3~5%. After this, they make nuclear fuel assembly called pellet which is a black, 1cm high column-shaped thing. In the nuclear power plant they generate electric energy from this pellet. One pellet can generate about 8 months’ electricity per one family which consist of 4 members. After 3~5 years of use, they will be sent to the reprocessing plant. 97% of them would be recycled. The reprocessing plant has an ability to deal with about 800t of the used pellets.

Nuclear fuel reprocessing is under the research in the Nuclear Fuel Cycle Facilities in Rokkasho village. They take out plutonium or uranium from the nuclear fuel which was already used in the Nuclear power generating station and make it into MOX fuel (Mixed Oxide Fuel), then use it again as a fuel. There are two types of natural uranium, which does nuclear fission; Uranium 235 and which doesn’t fission; Uranium 238, and only 0.7% of them is the Uranium 235. However, Uranium 238 can be changed into plutonium 239 reacting neutron in the atomic pile. After that, they put it into fast breeder:FBR and burn it. At this point, if they put Uranium 238 around the Plutonium together, they would be able to change the Uranium 238 into new plutonium at the same time, and produce more plutonium.

Since this reprocessing would be able to reduce the radioactivity of the waste Japanese government is making efforts to promote the research. Furthermore, the political situation of the countries which have a lot of uranium are relatively stable, therefore the security risks are low. Now, the Rokkasho village is taking care of the low level radio-active waste. Japanese government and Nuclear Waste Management Organization of Japan (NUMO)  now is looking for local governments which can allow having dumping grounds for radioactive wastes. They are aiming to decide some places by 2040. Since this is a big issue for all of us, each of us has to take this issue seriously and take some part of responsibilities. The advantage and risk of nuclear power are opposite side of the same coin. In the Rokkasho Visitors Center, they are making a lot of effort to let people know more about what the nuclear power is in detail. I think that the nuclear power plants are going to become the major source of electricity in next 50 years until the nuclear fusion power plant would be established. Until then, we have to learn about nuclear fission and radiation more, and support our energy supply.

Fusion Energy

To tell the truth, I didn’t know about the nuclear fusion at all until this field trip. I can say that this would be a dream energy resource for human beings in the future if they could generate electricity from this technology successfully. The process and the technology are very complicated and difficult to understand for me. My brief interpretation of this technology is that making small sun on the earth and getting energy from it. Nuclear fusion doesn’t emit radial ray or CO2 either. We can get the resources from the ocean. I think that the success of this project would be the key of solving the energy problem especially in Japan. Japan is surrounded by ocean and we don’t have many natural resources in country, therefore if we could use this technology in the future, we don’t have to suffer from the energy shortage anymore.  

Many countries such as EU, the US, Japan, Russia, China, Korea, and India are now working on this biggest scientific project in the world together. This means that more than 80% of the world population is supporting this project. I like this concept that many countries work hard on the global issue hand in hand. Europe is taking care of 20% of the major components of ITER, and 10% for other each country. I’m proud of that Japan is playing an important role in this project using well developed engineering and physics. Thanks to the detailed handout and well-organized presentation by two professors, I could roughly understand what is going on in the research center now and how to get energy from nuclear fusion. The only problems are that it costs a lot and takes decades to establish the DEMO reactor. I don’t know how much money they need exactly but I guess it would be hundreds of millions. I think this is the valuable principal investment but we always have to think about the balance of present life and the future life.

Conclusion

              In this paper, I briefly organized what I have learned in the Rokkasho Village, and discussed about the merit and demerit of the each energy recourse: 1) Fossil Fuel, 2) Wind Power, 3) Nuclear Power, and 4) Fusion Energy respectively.  As my conclusion, I would like to consider about the direction that we should take toward the future from my point of view.  As I already mentioned above, when we talk about this energy issue, we always should think about the balance of now and future. Fossil fuel is running out. Global warming is going on and the earth is jeopardized. These are the unchangeable facts.  I think that especially in next 50 years, we have to work on shifting energy resources into renewable energy resource and use the nuclear power plants and other technology with well balance. However, when it comes to the nuclear power, I still cannot fully agree with using this technology. Even though we can recycle the uranium, we still have to manage the wastes which would be really harmful if they leaked out.

              I mostly talked about how to get safer and more efficient energy until here, but I think we have to think about resolving underlying discrepancy. I mean only focusing on how to generate more energy and how about how reduce the carbon dioxide emission by CCS cannot solve the problem at the root. Therefore, we have to think about how to use energy less and how to cut CO2 emission off. Using more “eco-products”, trying to divide garbage then recycle things more, turning off electricity when it is not necessary and so on would be the effective way to face to the issue, for example. Even though each effort is small and seems useless, but I am sure that these kind of “acting locally” will help to solve the global issue eventually.